TY  - JOUR
AU  - Chen, Jinying
AU  - Cutrona, Sarah L
AU  - Dharod, Ajay
AU  - Bunch, Stephanie C
AU  - Foley, Kristie L
AU  - Ostasiewski, Brian
AU  - Hale, Erica R
AU  - Bridges, Aaron
AU  - Moses, Adam
AU  - Donny, Eric C
AU  - Sutfin, Erin L
AU  - Houston, Thomas K
PY  - 2023
DA  - 2023/3/2
TI  - Monitoring the Implementation of Tobacco Cessation Support Tools: Using Novel Electronic Health Record Activity Metrics
JO  - JMIR Med Inform
SP  - e43097
VL  - 11
KW  - medical informatics
KW  - electronic health records
KW  - EHR metrics
KW  - alerts
KW  - alert burden
KW  - tobacco cessation
KW  - monitoring
KW  - clinical decision support
KW  - implementation science
KW  - smoking cessation
KW  - decision tool
AB  - Background: Clinical decision support (CDS) tools in electronic health records (EHRs) are often used as core strategies to support quality improvement programs in the clinical setting. Monitoring the impact (intended and unintended) of these tools is crucial for program evaluation and adaptation. Existing approaches for monitoring typically rely on health care providers’ self-reports or direct observation of clinical workflows, which require substantial data collection efforts and are prone to reporting bias. Objective: This study aims to develop a novel monitoring method leveraging EHR activity data and demonstrate its use in monitoring the CDS tools implemented by a tobacco cessation program sponsored by the National Cancer Institute’s Cancer Center Cessation Initiative (C3I). Methods: We developed EHR-based metrics to monitor the implementation of two CDS tools: (1) a screening alert reminding clinic staff to complete the smoking assessment and (2) a support alert prompting health care providers to discuss support and treatment options, including referral to a cessation clinic. Using EHR activity data, we measured the completion (encounter-level alert completion rate) and burden (the number of times an alert was fired before completion and time spent handling the alert) of the CDS tools. We report metrics tracked for 12 months post implementation, comparing 7 cancer clinics (2 clinics implemented the screening alert and 5 implemented both alerts) within a C3I center, and identify areas to improve alert design and adoption. Results: The screening alert fired in 5121 encounters during the 12 months post implementation. The encounter-level alert completion rate (clinic staff acknowledged completion of screening in EHR: 0.55; clinic staff completed EHR documentation of screening results: 0.32) remained stable over time but varied considerably across clinics. The support alert fired in 1074 encounters during the 12 months. Providers acted upon (ie, not postponed) the support alert in 87.3% (n=938) of encounters, identified a patient ready to quit in 12% (n=129) of encounters, and ordered a referral to the cessation clinic in 2% (n=22) of encounters. With respect to alert burden, on average, both alerts fired over 2 times (screening alert: 2.7; support alert: 2.1) before completion; time spent postponing the screening alert was similar to completing (52 vs 53 seconds) the alert, and time spent postponing the support alert was more than completing (67 vs 50 seconds) the alert per encounter. These findings inform four areas where the alert design and use can be improved: (1) improving alert adoption and completion through local adaptation, (2) improving support alert efficacy by additional strategies including training in provider-patient communication, (3) improving the accuracy of tracking for alert completion, and (4) balancing alert efficacy with the burden. Conclusions: EHR activity metrics were able to monitor the success and burden of tobacco cessation alerts, allowing for a more nuanced understanding of potential trade-offs associated with alert implementation. These metrics can be used to guide implementation adaptation and are scalable across diverse settings. 
SN  - 2291-9694
UR  - https://medinform.jmir.org/2023/1/e43097
UR  - https://doi.org/10.2196/43097
UR  - http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36862466
DO  - 10.2196/43097
ID  - info:doi/10.2196/43097
ER  -